Institutionalization of the Regional Administrative Elite: Recruitment Pool and Career Trajectories
Research Article
Acknowledgments
The study was carried out with the financial support of the Russian Foundation for Basic Research and the Autonomous non-commercial organization Expert Institute for Social Research within the framework of scientific project No. 21-011-31304/21 “Institutionalization of the regional administrative elite: recruitment pool and career trajectories”.
How to Cite
Bystrova A.S., Daugavet A.B., Duka A.V., Kolesnik N.V., Nevskiy A.V., Tev D.B. Institutionalization of the Regional Administrative Elite: Recruitment Pool and Career Trajectories. Vlast i Elity (Power and Elites). 2021. Vol. 8. No. 2. P. 21–54. DOI: https://doi.org/10.31119/pe.2021.8.2.2 (in Russ.).
Abstract
The article presents the analysis of studies devoted to the pool of recruitment and career trajectories of the administrative elite from the point of view of the problem of its institutionalization. The importance of studying the sociodemographic and socioprofessional characteristics of the administrative elite is related to the fact that it not only clarifies the structure of social and political power that underlies elite recruitment, but also allows us to better understand the political attitudes and behavior of senior officials. Moreover, the degree of homogeneity of the pool of recruitment of the administrative elite can influence the level of its cohesion. In domestic and foreign literature, such important trends in the recruitment of the federal administrative elite of Russia as professionalization, nomenclaturization, militarization and plutocratization are identified and analyzed, and its gender and educational characteristics are shown. However, at the regional level, the main attention was paid to the governors, while the administrative elite as a whole remains insufficiently studied, especially in connection with the problem of its institutionalization in the context of the transformation of Russian society. It seems that from this point of view, it is necessary to study the sources and channels of recruitment of the key officials in dynamics, over a long period of time, which makes it possible to compare their sociodemographic and socioprofessional characteristics in different historical periods with the specific opportunity structure of administrative career inherent in them.
Keywords:
administrative elite, institutionalization, career trajectories, recruitment, region, professionalization, gender
References
1. Aivazova S.G. Gendernye osobennosti politicheskogo povedenija rossijan v kontekste izbiratel’nogo cikla parlamentskih i prezidentskih vyborov 2011–2012 gg. [Gender characteristics of the political behavior of Russians in the context of the electoral cycle of the 2011–2012 parliamentary and presidential elections]. In: Zhenshhina v rossijskom obshhestve [Woman in Russian society], 2012, 3, pp. 3–11. (In Russian)
2. Buckley N., Garifullina G., Reuter J., Frye T. Politjekonomija vyborov i naznachenij gubernatorov v Rossii [The Political Economy of Russian Gubernatorial Election and Appointment]: Preprint WP1/2013/04. M.: HSE, 2013. 36 p. URL: http://netess.ru/3knigi/921186–1-n-bakli-garifullina-reyter-fray-politekonomiya-viborov-naznacheniy-gubernatorov-rossii-preprint-wp1-2013-04-seriya-wp1.php (accessed: 31.03.2020). (In Russian)
3. Barsegjan V.M. Modeli kar’ernyh traektorij glav rossijskih regionov [Models of Career Trajectories of the Heads of Russian Regions], Polis. Politicheskie issledovanija [Polis. Political Studies], 2019, 4, pp. 132–148. (In Russian)
4. Borshchevsky G.A. Vysshie gosudarstvennye sluzhashhie kak politiko-administrativnaja jelita sovremennoj Rossii [Senior Civil Servants as Russian Political and Administrative Elite], Politija [Politeia], 2018, 1 (88), pp. 82–99. (In Russian)
5. Bystrova A.S. Otstavki i vybory 2018 g.: obnovlenie gubernatorskogo korpusa, bassejn rekrutirovanija i kar’ery novyh personazhej [Resignation and Election of 2018: Update Governors, Pool Recruiting and Career of New Characters], Vlast’ i jelity [Power and Elites], 2018, 5, pp. 331–359. https://doi.org/10.31119/pe.2018.5.12. (In Russian)
6. Bystrova A.S., Daugavet A.B., Duka A.V., Kolesnik N.V., Nevskij A.V., Tev D.B. Institucionalizacija politicheskoj jelity: istochniki rekrutirovanija i kar’era [Institutionalization of the Political Elite: Sources of Recruitment and Career], Vlast’ i jelity [Power and Elites], 2019, 6 (2), pp. 24–66. https://doi.org/10.31119/pe.2019.6.2.2 (In Russian)
7. Bystrova A.S., Duka A.V. Korrupcija v institucionalizacii rossijskoj jelity [Corruption in the institutionalization of the Russian elite], Finansy i biznes [Finance and Business], 2006, 1, pp 57–67. (In Russian)
8. Voronkova O.A., Sidorova A.A., Kryshtanovskaja O.V. Rossijskij isteblishment: puti i metody obnovlenija [Russian Establishment: Ways and Methods of Renewal], Polis. Politicheskie issledovanija [Polis. Political Studies], 2011, 1, pp. 66–79. (In Russian)
9. Gaman-Golutvina O.V. Politicheskie jelity Rossii: Vehi istoricheskoj jevoljucii [Political Elites of Russia: Milestones of Historical Evolution]. Moscow: ROSSPEN, 2006. 446 p.
10. Gaman-Golutvina O.V. Regional’nye jelity Rossii: personal’nyj sostav i tendencii jevoljucii (I) [Regional Elites of Russia: Personal Composition and Trends of Evolution (I)], Polis. Politicheskie issledovanija [Polis. Political Studies], 2004a, 2, pp. 6–19. (In Russian)
11. Gaman-Golutvina O.V. Regional’nye jelity Rossii: personal’nyj sostav i tendencii jevoljucii (II) [Regional Elites of Russia: Personal Composition and Trends of Evolution (II)], Polis. Politicheskie issledovanija [Polis. Political Studies], 2004b, 3, pp. 22–32. (In Russian)
12. Gutorov V.A. Intolerantnost’ kak faktor politicheskogo processa v postkommunisticheskih stranah [Intolerance as a Factor of the Political Process in PostCommunist Countries], Vestnik SanktPeterburgskogo universiteta. Politologija. Mezhdunarodnye otnoshenija [Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Politology. International Relations], 2008, 1, pp.13–24. (In Russian)
13. Duka A.V. Institucionalizacija rossijskoj politiko–administrativnoj jelity [Institutionalization of the Russian political and administrative elite], Politicheskaja nauka [Political Science], 2009, 3, pp. 110–140. (In Russian)
14. Duka A.V. K voprosu o militokratii: Siloviki v regional’nyh vlastnyh jelitah [On the issue of militocracy: Siloviki in regional power elites]. In: Vlastnye struktury i gruppy dominirovanija: Materialy desjatogo Vserossijskogo seminara “Sociologicheskie problemy institutov vlasti v uslovijah rossijskoj transformacii” [Power structures and groups of domination: Materials of the tenth All-Russian seminar “Sociological problems of power institutions in the context of Russian transformation”]. Ed. by A. Duka. St. Petersburg: Intersotsis, 2012, pp. 94–120. (In Russian)
15. Duka A.V. Postsovetskaja jelita: institucionalizacija i rekrutirovanie [Post-Soviet Elite: Institutionalization and Recruitment]. In: Politicheskie instituty Rossii i Francii: Tradicii i sovremennost’ [Political Institutions of Russia and France: Traditions and Modernity]. Ed. by Efremenko D.V., Lapina N.Ju. Moscow: INION RUS, 2014, pp.203–228. (In Russian)
16. Duka A.V. Problemy institucionalizacii rossijskoj politiko-administrativnoj jelity: jekonomicheskij i global’nyj aspekty [Problems of institutionalization of the Russian political and administrative elite: economic and global aspects]. In: Vlast’ i jelity v sovremennoj Rossii [Power and elites in modern Russia]. Ed. by A.V. Duka. St. Petersburg: Sociologicheskoe obshhestvo imeni M.M. Kovalevskogo, 2003, pp. 162–186. (In Russian)
17. Duka A.V. Transformacija mestnyh jelit: (institucionalizacija obshhestvennyh dvizhenij: ot protesta k uchastiju) [Transformation of local elites: (institutionalization of social movements: from protest to participation)], Mir Rossii [Universe of Russia], 1995, 4 (2), pp. 106–117. (In Russian)
18. Zudin A. Gosudarstvo i biznes v Rossii: jevoljucija modeli vzaimootnoshenij [State and business in Russia: evolution of the relationship model], Neprikosnovennyj zapas [NZ], 2006, 6 (50). URL: http://www.intelros.ru/?newsid=289 (accessed: 21.03.2019). (In Russian)
19. Kashina M.A. Zhenshhiny v rossijskih parlamentah: perejdet li kolichestvo v kachestvo? Kejs Zakonodatel’nogo Sobranija Sankt-Peterburga [Women in Russian Parliaments: Will Quantity Become Quality?], Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Filosofija. Sociologija. Politologija [Tomsk State University Journal of Philosophy Sociology and Political Science], 2020, 54, pp. 238–251. (In Russian)
20. Kolesnik N.V. Gendernye raspredelenija v regional’noj jelite (severo-zapad i jug Rossii) [Gender distributions in the regional elite (northwest and south of Russia)], Politicheskaja jekspertiza: Politeks [Political Expertise: Politex], 2009, 5 (2), pp. 72–87. (In Russian)
21. Kolesnik N.V. Gendernoe (ne) ravenstvo v politicheskoj vlasti rossijskih regionov [Gender (In)Equality in the Political Power of Russian Regions], Monitoring obshhestvennogo mnenija: jekonomicheskie i social’nye peremeny [Monitoring of Public Opinion: Economic and Social Changes], 2021, 4, pp. 468–491. (In Russian)
22. Kryshtanovskaya O.V. Biznes-jelita i oligarhi: itogi desjatiletija [Business elite and oligarchs: results of the decade], Mir Rossii [Universe of Russia], 2002a, 4, pp. 3–60. (In Russian)
23. Kryshtanovskaja O.V. Rezhim Putina: liberal’naja militokratija? [Putin’s Regime: A Liberal Militocracy?], Pro et Contra, 2002b, 7 (4), pp. 158–180. (In Russian)
24. Kryshtanovskaja O. Transformacija staroj nomenklatury v novuju sovetskuju jelitu [Transformation of the old nomenklatura into the new Soviet elite], Obshhestvennye nauki i sovremennost’ [Social Sciences and Contemporary World], 1995, 1, pp. 51–65. (In Russian)
25. Kynev A.V. Fenomen gubernatorov-«varjagov» kak indikator recentralizacii: opyt 1991–2018 gg. [Phenomenon of Governors-“Outsiders” as Indicator OF Recentralization Experience of 1991—2018 Years], Politija [Politeia], 2019, 2 (93), pp. 125–150. (In Russian)
26. Larin A.A. Ljustracija kak osnovanie ogranichenija izbiratel’nogo prava [Lustration as a basis for restricting suffrage], Teorija i praktika obshhestvennogo razvitija [Theory and Practice of Social Development], 2014, 4, pp. 246–249. (In Russian)
27. Leshkevich T.G., Ponomareva M.A. Transformacija jelit i processy modernizacii na Juge Rossii [Transformation of elites and modernization processes in the South of Russia]. Rostov-on-Don: SFU, 2011. 262 p. (In Russian)
28. Lezina E.V. Ljustracija i otkrytie arhivov v ctranah Central’noj i Vostochnoj Evropy [Lustration and File Access in the Countries of Central and Eastern Europe], Vestnik obshhestvennogo mnenija. Dannye. Analiz. Diskussii [The Russian Public Opinion Herald. Data. Analysis. Discussions], 2015, 2 (120), pp.48–89. (In Russian)
29. Muhametov R.S. Rol’ dekommunizacii v politicheskom tranzite gosudarstv Vostochnoj Evropy [The Role of Decommunization in the Political Transition of the States of Eastern Europe], Vestnik Omskogo universiteta. Serija «Istoricheskie nauki» [Herald of Omsk University. Series Historical Studies], 2018, 1 (17), 204–210. https://doi.org/10.25513/2312-1300.2018.1.204-210. (In Russian)
30. Muhametov R.S., Nagornyh O.V. Dekommunizacija v Vostochnoj Evrope: sushhnost’, prichiny i meroprijatija [Decommunization in Eastern Europe: Essence, Causes and Activities], Vestnik Omskogo universiteta. Serija «Istoricheskie nauki» [Herald of Omsk University. Series Historical Studies], 2018, 2 (18). pp. 201–207. https://doi.org/10.25513/2312-1300.2018.2.201-207. (In Russian)
31. Nisnevich Ju.A. Regeneracija nomenklatury kak pravjashhego social’nogo sloja v postsovetskoj Rossii [Regeneration of the nomenclature as a ruling social stratum in post-Soviet Russia], Sociologicheskie issledovanija [Sociological Studies], 2018, 8, pp. 143–152. (In Russian)
32. Obolonsky A.V. Ljustracija kak institut perioda tranzita: pljusy i minusy [Lustration as an Institute of the Transit Period: Pros and Cons], Voprosy teoreticheskoj jekonomiki [Theoretical Economics], 2020, 4, pp. 87–101. (In Russian)
33. Ovcharova O.G. Gendernaja asimmetrija v sfere politiki: poiski institucional’nogo reshenija problem [Gender asymmetry in politics: the search for an institutional solution to the problem], Vestnik Saratovskoj gosudarstvennoj akademii prava [Saratov State Law Academy Bulletin], 2007, № 5 (57), pp. 214–219. (In Russian)
34. Pushkareva N.L. Gde bol’she vlasti — tam men’she zhenshhin (gendernaja jekspertiza zakonodatel’stva i tekushhej zakonotvorcheskoj dejatel’nosti vysshih organov vlasti RF 1991–2006 g.) [Where there is more power, there are fewer women (gender expertise of legislation and current legislative activities of the highest authorities of the Russian Federation, 1991–2006)], Nauchnye vedomosti Belgorodskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Serija: Istorija. Politologija [Belgorod State University Scientific Bulletin. History and Political Science], 2008, 1 (41), pp. 117–127. (In Russian)
35. Regional’nye jelity SeveroZapada Rossii: politicheskie i jekonomicheskie orientacii [Regional Elites of Russia’s North-West: Political and Economical Orientations]. Ed. by A.V. Duka. St. Petersburg: Aletejja, 2001. 352 p. (In Russian)
36. Rivera S, Rivera D. K bolee tochnym ocenkam transformacii v rossijskoj jelite [Towards More Accurate Estimates of the Transformation in the Russian Elite], Polis. Politicheskie issledovanija [Polis. Political Studies], 2009, 5, pp. 149–157. (In Russian)
37. Samye vlijatel’nye ljudi Rossii. Politicheskie i jekonomicheskie jelity rossijskih regionov [The most influential people in Russia. Political and economic elites of Russian regions]. Ed. by Gaman-Golutvina O.V. Moscow: ISANT, 2004. 696 p. (In Russian)
38. Safronov V.V. Konsolidacija avtoritarizma ili demokratizacija: podderzhka putinskogo rezhima jelitoj S.-Peterburga [Consolidation of authoritarianism or democratization: support of the Putin regime by the elite of St. Petersburg]. In: Uslovija i vozmozhnosti konsolidacii rossijskogo obshhestva [Conditions and opportunities for the consolidation of Russian society]. Ed. by A.V. Duka, I.I. Eliseeva. St. Petersburg: Nestor-Istorija, 2010, pp. 30–110. (In Russian)
39. Sergeev S.A., Zinnatullin A.Z. Gubernatorskij korpus v 2005–2012 gg.: kar’ernye traektorii [Governor’s Corps 2005–2012: Career Trajectories], Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Serija: politologija [Bulletin of Perm University. Political Science], 2014, 4, pp. 122–136. (In Russian)
40. Sillaste G. Zhenskie jelity Rossii i ih osobennosti [Women’s elites of Russia and their features], Obshhestvennye nauki i sovremennost’ [Social Sciences and Contemporary World], 1994, 1, pp. 112–121 (In Russian)
41. Smirnov V.A. Litovskaja diaspora v SShA kak kanal jelitnogo rekrutirovanija v postsovetskoj Litve [Lithuanian Diaspora in the USA as an Elite Recruitment Channel in Post-Soviet Lithuania]. In: Vlastnye struktury i gruppy dominirovanija: Materialy desjatogo Vserossijskogo seminara “Sociologicheskie problemy institutov vlasti v uslovijah rossijskoj transformacii” [Power Structures and Dominance Groups: Materials of the Tenth All-Russian Seminar “Sociological Problems of Power Institutions in the Context of Russian Transformation”]. Ed. by A.V. Duka. St. Petersburg: Intersocis, 2012, pp. 40–51. (In Russian)
42. Tev D.B. Vysokopostavlennye chinovniki Administracii Prezidenta RF: kanaly rekrutirovanija i kar’era [Senior Officials of the Presidential Administration of Russia: Recruitment Channels and Career], Zhurnal Sotsiologii i Sotsialnoy Antropologii [The Journal of Sociology and Social Anthropology], 2020, 23 (3), pp. 153–187. (In Russian)
43. Tev D.B. Gosudarstvennaja Duma RF shestogo sozyva: social’no-professional’nye harakteristiki bassejna rekrutirovanija deputatov [State Duma the sixth convocation: socio-professional characteristics of the recruiting pool of deputies]. In. Vlast’ i jelity [Power and Elites], 4. Ed. by A.V. Duka. St. Petersburg: Intersocis, 2017, pp. 67–128. (In Russian)
44. Tev D.B. Partii «vtorogo jeshelona» v regional’nyh parlamentah: osobennosti bassejna rekrutirovanija deputatov KPRF, Spravedlivoj Rossii i LDPR [Parties of the “second echelon” in regional parliaments: features of the pool of recruiting deputies of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation, A Just Russia and the Liberal Democratic Party], Vestnik Permskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Serija «Politologija» [Bulletin of Perm University. Political Science], 2012, 1 (17), pp. 98–111. (In Russian)
45. Tev D.B. Federal’naja administrativnaja jelita Rossii: kar’ernye puti i kanaly rekrutirovanija [Federal Administrative Elite of Russia: Career Paths and Channels of Recruitment], Polis. Politicheskie issledovanija [Polis. Political Studies], 2016a, 4, pp. 115–130. (In Russian)
46. Tev D.B. Federal’naja administrativnaja jelita Rossii: obrazovatel’nye harakteristiki [Russia’s Federal Administrative Elite: Educational Characteristics], Mir Rossii [Universe of Russia], 2016b, 3, pp. 76–96. (In Russian)
47. Turovsky R.F. Regional’nye politicheskie rezhimy: k metodologii analiza [Regional Political Regimes: Toward a Methodology of Analysis], Polis. Politicheskie issledovanija [Polis. Political Studies], 2009, 2, pp. 77–95. (In Russian)
48. Flyagin A.M. Kak izmenilsya portret rossijskogo gubernatora: analiz biografij glav regionov. 1991–2019 [How the Portrait of the Russian Governor has changed: analysing Biographies of the Heads of Russian Regions. 1991–2019], Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. POLITOLOGIYA [Bulletin of Perm University. Political Science], 2020, 14 (1), pp. 29–39. (In Russian)
49. Hasbulatova O.A. Gendernyj podhod kak tehnologija povyshenija jeffektivnosti kadrovoj politiki [Gender approach as a technology for increasing the effectiveness of personnel policy], Zhenshhina v rossijskom obshhestve [Woman in Russian society], 2014, 4 (73), pp. 3–31. (In Russian)
50. Huntington S. Politicheskij porjadok v menjajushhihsja obshhestvah [Political Order in Changing Societies]. Moscow: Progress-Tradicija, 2004. 480 p. (In Russian)
51. Chirikova A.E., Lapina N.Ju. Zhenshhina na vysshih jetazhah vlasti. Rossijskie praktiki i francuzskij opyt [A woman on the highest echelons of power. Russian practices and French experience], Informacionnoanaliticheskij bjulleten’ Instituta sociologii Rossijskoj akademii nauk [Information and analytical bulletin of the Institute of Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences]. Moscow: Institute of Sociology of RUS, 2009. 72 p. (In Russian)
52. Shentjakova A.V. Politicheskaja i administrativnaja jelita: kachestvennyj sostav i kanaly rekrutirovanija [Political and Administrative Elite: Qualitative Composition and Recruitment Channels]. In: Rossijskie vlastnye instituty i jelity v transformacii: Materialy vos’mogo Vserossijskogo seminara «Sociologicheskie problemy institutov vlasti v uslovijah rossijskoj transformacii» [Russian Power Institutions and Elites in Transformation: Proceedings of the Eighth All-Russian Seminar “Sociological Problems of Power Institutions in the Context of Russian Transformation”]. Ed by A.V. Duka. St. Petersburg: Intersocis, 2011, pp. 145–156. (In Russian)
53. Bennett A.J. The American President’s Cabinet: From Kennedy to Bush. London: Palgrave Macmillan UK, 1996. xvi, 263 p.
54. Bermeo N. Ministerial Elites in Southern Europe: Continuities, Changes and Comparisons // Who Governs Southern Europe? Regime Change and Ministerial Recruitment, 1850 2000 / ed. by P. Tavares de Almeida, A.C. Pinto, N. Bermeo. London: Frank Cass Publishers, 2003. P. 191–212.
55. Bureaucratic Elites in Western European States. A Comparative Analysis of Top Officials / ed. by E.C. Page, V. Wright. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999. xi, 286 p.
56. Burton M.G., Higley J. Elite Settlements // American Sociological Review. 1987. Vol. 52, № 3. P. 295–307.
57. Burton M.G., Higley J. Political Crises and Elite Settlements // Elites, Crises, and the Origins of Regimes / ed. by M. Dogan, J. Higley. Lanham; Boulder; New York; London: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc., 1998. P. 47–70.
58. Burton M.G., Higley J. The Study of Political Elite Transformations // International Review of Sociology. 2001. Vol. 11, № 2. P. 181–199.
59. Burton M., Gunther R.; Higley J. Introduction: elite transformations and democratic regimes // Elites and Democratic Consolidation in Latin America and Southern Europe / ed. by J. Higley, R. Gunther. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992. P. 1–37.
60. Calder K. Elites in an Equalizing Role: Ex-Bureaucrats as Coordinators and Intermediaries in the Japanese Government-Business Relationship // Comparative Politics. Vol. 21, № 4. P. 379–403.
61. Claveria S., Verge T. Post-ministerial Occupation in Advanced Industrial Democracies: Ambition, Individual Resources and Institutional Opportunity Structures // European Journal of Political Research. 2015. Vol. 54, № 4. P. 819–835.
62. Cotta M., Verzichelli L. Ministers in Italy: Notables, Party Men, Technocrats and Media Men // Who Governs Southern Europe? Regime Change and Ministerial Recruitment, 1850 2000 / ed. by P. Tavares de Almeida, A.C. Pinto, N. Bermeo. London: Frank Cass Publishers, 2003. P. 109–142.
63. Dahrendorf R. Society and Democracy in Germany. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday & Company, Inc., 1969. xvi, 457 p.
64. Davis R.H. Women and Power in Parliamentary Democracies: Cabinet Appointments in Western Europe, 1968–1992. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1997. xi, 137 p.
65. De Almeida P.T., Pinto A.C. Portuguese ministers, 1851–1999: Social background and paths to power // Who governs Southern Europe? Regime change and ministerial recruitment, 1850–2000 / ed. by P. Tavares de Almeida, A. Costa Pinto, N. Bermeo. London; Portland, OR: F. Cass, 2003. P. 4–38.
66. Demin A., Libman A., Eras L. Post-socialist transition, authoritarian consolidation and social origin of political elites: the case of Russian regional governors // Eurasian Geography and Economics. 2019. https://doi.org/10.1080/15387216.2019.1676809.
67. Domhoff G.W. Who Rules America? Power, Politics and Social Change. 5th ed. Boston, Mass.: McGraw-Hill, 2006. xviii, 265 p.
68. Dye T.R., Pickering J.W. Governmental and Corporate Elites: Convergence and Differentiation // The Journal of Politics. 1974. Vol. 36, № 4. P. 900–925.
69. Edinger L., Searing D. Social Background in Elite Analysis: A Methodological Inquiry // American Political Science Review. 1967. Vol. 61, № 2. P. 428–445.
70. Etzion D., Davis G.F. Revolving Doors? A Network Analysis of Corporate Officers and U.S. Government Officials // Journal of Management Inquiry. 2008. Vol. 17, № 3. P. 157–161.
71. Field G.L., Higley J. Elitism. London; Boston: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1980. xi, 135 p.
72. Fischer J., Kaiser A. Hiring and Firing Ministers under Informal Constraints. Germany // The Selection of Ministers in Europe: Hiring and Firing / ed. by K. Dowding, P. Dumont. London; New York: Routledge, 2009. P. 21–40.
73. Francis S. Institutionalizing Elites: Political Elite Formation and Change in the KwaZulu-Natal Provincial Legislature. Leiden; Boston: Brill, 2011. xii, 321 p.
74. Freitag P.J. The Cabinet and Big Business: A Study of Interlocks // Social Problems. 1975. Vol. 23, № 2. P. 137–152.
75. GamanGolutvina O. Changes in Elite Patterns // Europe-Asia Studies. 2008. Vol. 60, № 6. P. 1033–1050.
76. Giddens A. Elites in the British class structure // Elites and Power in British Society / ed. by P. Stanworth, A. Giddens. London: Cambridge University Press, 1974. P. 1–21.
77. Gill G. Bourgeoisie, State, and Democracy: Russia, Britain, France, Germany, and the USA. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008. 396 p.
78. Gulbrandsen T. Elite Integration — An Empirical Study // Historical Social Research — Historische Sozialforschung. 2012. Vol. 37, № 1. Special Issue: Elite Foundations. P. 148–166.
79. Gulbrandsen T. Elite Integration and Institutional Trust in Norway // Comparative Sociology. 2007. Vol. 6, № 1–2. P. 190–214.
80. Hartmann M. Elites and Power Structure // Handbook of European Societies. Social Transformations in the 21st Century / Ed. by Immerfall S., Therborn G. Berlin; New York: Springer, 2010. P. 291–323.
81. Higley J., Burton M. Elite foundations of liberal democracy. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, 2006. vii, 229 p.
82. HoffmannLange U. Theory-Based Typologies of Political Elites // The Palgrave Handbook of Political Elites / ed. by H. Best, J. Higley. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2018. P. 53–68.
83. Huskey E. Elite Recruitment and State-society Relations in Technocratic Authoritarian Regimes: The Russian Case // Communist and Post-Communist Studies. 2010a. Vol. 43, № 4. P. 363–372.
84. Huskey E. Pantouflage à la russe: The Recruitment of Russian Political and Business Elites // Russian Politics from Lenin to Putin / ed. by S.P. Fortescue. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2010b. P. 185–204.
85. Kam C., Indridason I. Cabinet Dynamics and Ministerial Careers in the French Fifth Republic // The Selection of Ministers in Europe: Hiring and Firing / ed. by K. Dowding, P. Dumont. London; New York: Routledge, 2009. P. 41–57.
86. Keller S. Beyond the Ruling Class: Strategic Elites in Modern Society. With a New Introduction by the Author. New Brunswick; London: Transaction Publishers, 1991. xxv, 354 p.
87. Kerbo H.R., McKinstry J.A. Who Rules Japan? The Inner Circles of Economic and Political Power. Westport, CT: Praeger, 1995. viii, 217 p.
88. Kim C.L., Patterson S.C. Parliamentary Elite Integration in Six Nations // Comparative Politics. 1988. Vol. 20, № 4. P. 379–399.
89. Kryshtanovskaya O., White S. From Soviet Nomenklatura to Russian Elite // Europe-Asia Studies. 1996. Vol. 48, № 5. P. 711–733.
90. Kryshtanovskaya O., White S. Putin’s Militocracy // Post-Soviet Affairs. 2003. Vol. 19, № 4. P. 289–306.
91. Kryshtanovskaya O., White S. The Sovietization of Russian Politics // Post-Soviet Affairs. 2009. Vol. 25, № 4. P. 283–309.
92. Linz J.J., Jerez M., Corzo S. Ministers and Regimes in Spain: From the First to the Second Restoration, 1874–2002 // Who governs Southern Europe? Regime change and ministerial recruitment, 1850–2000 / ed. by P. Tavares de Almeida, A. Costa Pinto, N. Bermeo. London; Portland, OR: F. Cass, 2003. P. 38–108.
93. Matthews D.R. United States Senators and the Class Structure // Public Opinion Quarterly. 1954. Vol. 18, № 1. P. 5–22.
94. O’Donnell G., Schmitter P. Transitions from Authoritarian Rule. Tentative Conclusions about Uncertain Democracies. Baltimore; London: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1986.
95. Petrov N. Siloviki in Russian Regions: New Dogs, Old Tricks // The Journal of Power Institutions in Post-Soviet Societies. 2005. № 2. URL: http://www.pipss.org/index331.html.
96. Pinto A.C. Coping with the Double Legacy of Authoritarianism and Revolution in Portuguese Democracy // South European Society and Politics. 2010. Vol. 15, № 3. P. 395–412.
97. Pinto A.C. Political Purges and State Crisis in Portugal’s Transition to Democracy, 1975–76 // Journal of Contemporary History Copyright. 2008. Vol. 43, № 2. P. 305– 332.
98. Pinto A.C., de Almeida P.T. Portugal: the primacy of ‘independents’ // The Selection of Ministers in Europe: Hiring and Firing / ed. by K. Dowding, P. Dumont. London; New York: Routledge, 2009. P. 147–158.
99. Putnam R.D. The Beliefs of Politicians: Ideology, Conflict, and Democracy in Britain and Italy. New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1973. xii, 309 p.
100. Putnam R.D. The Comparative Study of Political Elites, Englewood Cliff s, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, 1976. x, 246 p.
101. Putnam R.D. Elite Transformation in Advanced Industrial Societies: An Empirical Assessment of the Theory of Technocracy // Comparative Political Studies. 1977. Vol. 10, № 3. P. 383–412.
102. Renz B. Putin’s militocracy? An alternative interpretation of Siloviki in contemporary Russian politics // Europe-Asia Studies. 2006. Vol. 58, № 6. P. 903–924.
103. Rivera D.W., Rivera S.W. Is Russia a militocracy? Conceptual issues and extant findings regarding elite militarization // Post-Soviet Affairs. 2014. Vol. 30, № 1. P. 27–50.
104. Rivera S.W., Rivera D.W. The Russian Elite under Putin: Militocratic or Bourgeois? // Post-Soviet Affairs. 2006. Vol. 22, № 2. P. 125–145.
105. Robins R.S. Political Institutionalization and the Integration of Elites. Beverly Hills, Calif.; London: Sage, 1976. vi, 221 p.
106. Rouban L. The Senior Civil Service in France // Bureaucratic Elites in Western European States. A Comparative Analysis of Top Officials / ed. by E.C. Page, V. Wright. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999. P. 65–89.
107. Schmidt C. Japan’s Circle of Power: Legitimacy and Integration of a National Elite // ASIEN — The German Journal on Contemporary Asia. 2005, № 96. P. 46–67.
108. Semenova E. Ministerial and Parliamentary Elites in Executive-Dominated System: Post-Soviet Russia 1991–2009 // Comparative Sociology. 2011. Vol. 10, № 6. P. 908–927.
109. Semenova E. Russia: Cabinet Formation and Careers in a Super-presidential System // The Selection of Ministers around the World / ed. by K. Dowding, P. Dumont. London; New York: Routledge, 2015. P. 139–155.
110. Szakony D. Politics for Profit: Business, Elections, and Policymaking in Russia. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press, 2020. 350 p.
111. Technocratic Ministers and Political Leadership in European Democracies / ed. by A.C. Pinto, M. Cotta, P. Tavares de Almeida. London: Palgrave, 2018. xiv, 295 p.
112. The Profession of Government Minister in Western Europe / ed. by J. Blondel, J.-L. Thiebault. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 1991. 215 p.
113. The Selection of Ministers in Europe: Hiring and Firing / ed. by K. Dowding, P. Dumont. London; New York: Routledge, 2009. 256 p.
114. Wasilewski J. Hungary, Poland, and Russia: The Fate of Nomenklatura Elites // Elites, Crises, and the Origins of Regimes / ed. by M. Dogan, J. Higley. Lanham; Boulder; New York; London: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc., 1998. P. 147–167.
115. Who Governs Southern Europe? Regime Change and Ministerial Recruitment, 1850–2000 / ed. by P. Tavares de Almeida, A.C. Pinto, N. Bermeo. London: Frank Cass Publishers, 2003. 242 p.
116. Williams K., Fowler B., Szczerbiak A. Explaining Lustration in Central Europe: A “Post-communist Politics” Approach // Democratization. 2005. Vol. 12, № 1. P. 22–43.
2. Buckley N., Garifullina G., Reuter J., Frye T. Politjekonomija vyborov i naznachenij gubernatorov v Rossii [The Political Economy of Russian Gubernatorial Election and Appointment]: Preprint WP1/2013/04. M.: HSE, 2013. 36 p. URL: http://netess.ru/3knigi/921186–1-n-bakli-garifullina-reyter-fray-politekonomiya-viborov-naznacheniy-gubernatorov-rossii-preprint-wp1-2013-04-seriya-wp1.php (accessed: 31.03.2020). (In Russian)
3. Barsegjan V.M. Modeli kar’ernyh traektorij glav rossijskih regionov [Models of Career Trajectories of the Heads of Russian Regions], Polis. Politicheskie issledovanija [Polis. Political Studies], 2019, 4, pp. 132–148. (In Russian)
4. Borshchevsky G.A. Vysshie gosudarstvennye sluzhashhie kak politiko-administrativnaja jelita sovremennoj Rossii [Senior Civil Servants as Russian Political and Administrative Elite], Politija [Politeia], 2018, 1 (88), pp. 82–99. (In Russian)
5. Bystrova A.S. Otstavki i vybory 2018 g.: obnovlenie gubernatorskogo korpusa, bassejn rekrutirovanija i kar’ery novyh personazhej [Resignation and Election of 2018: Update Governors, Pool Recruiting and Career of New Characters], Vlast’ i jelity [Power and Elites], 2018, 5, pp. 331–359. https://doi.org/10.31119/pe.2018.5.12. (In Russian)
6. Bystrova A.S., Daugavet A.B., Duka A.V., Kolesnik N.V., Nevskij A.V., Tev D.B. Institucionalizacija politicheskoj jelity: istochniki rekrutirovanija i kar’era [Institutionalization of the Political Elite: Sources of Recruitment and Career], Vlast’ i jelity [Power and Elites], 2019, 6 (2), pp. 24–66. https://doi.org/10.31119/pe.2019.6.2.2 (In Russian)
7. Bystrova A.S., Duka A.V. Korrupcija v institucionalizacii rossijskoj jelity [Corruption in the institutionalization of the Russian elite], Finansy i biznes [Finance and Business], 2006, 1, pp 57–67. (In Russian)
8. Voronkova O.A., Sidorova A.A., Kryshtanovskaja O.V. Rossijskij isteblishment: puti i metody obnovlenija [Russian Establishment: Ways and Methods of Renewal], Polis. Politicheskie issledovanija [Polis. Political Studies], 2011, 1, pp. 66–79. (In Russian)
9. Gaman-Golutvina O.V. Politicheskie jelity Rossii: Vehi istoricheskoj jevoljucii [Political Elites of Russia: Milestones of Historical Evolution]. Moscow: ROSSPEN, 2006. 446 p.
10. Gaman-Golutvina O.V. Regional’nye jelity Rossii: personal’nyj sostav i tendencii jevoljucii (I) [Regional Elites of Russia: Personal Composition and Trends of Evolution (I)], Polis. Politicheskie issledovanija [Polis. Political Studies], 2004a, 2, pp. 6–19. (In Russian)
11. Gaman-Golutvina O.V. Regional’nye jelity Rossii: personal’nyj sostav i tendencii jevoljucii (II) [Regional Elites of Russia: Personal Composition and Trends of Evolution (II)], Polis. Politicheskie issledovanija [Polis. Political Studies], 2004b, 3, pp. 22–32. (In Russian)
12. Gutorov V.A. Intolerantnost’ kak faktor politicheskogo processa v postkommunisticheskih stranah [Intolerance as a Factor of the Political Process in PostCommunist Countries], Vestnik SanktPeterburgskogo universiteta. Politologija. Mezhdunarodnye otnoshenija [Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Politology. International Relations], 2008, 1, pp.13–24. (In Russian)
13. Duka A.V. Institucionalizacija rossijskoj politiko–administrativnoj jelity [Institutionalization of the Russian political and administrative elite], Politicheskaja nauka [Political Science], 2009, 3, pp. 110–140. (In Russian)
14. Duka A.V. K voprosu o militokratii: Siloviki v regional’nyh vlastnyh jelitah [On the issue of militocracy: Siloviki in regional power elites]. In: Vlastnye struktury i gruppy dominirovanija: Materialy desjatogo Vserossijskogo seminara “Sociologicheskie problemy institutov vlasti v uslovijah rossijskoj transformacii” [Power structures and groups of domination: Materials of the tenth All-Russian seminar “Sociological problems of power institutions in the context of Russian transformation”]. Ed. by A. Duka. St. Petersburg: Intersotsis, 2012, pp. 94–120. (In Russian)
15. Duka A.V. Postsovetskaja jelita: institucionalizacija i rekrutirovanie [Post-Soviet Elite: Institutionalization and Recruitment]. In: Politicheskie instituty Rossii i Francii: Tradicii i sovremennost’ [Political Institutions of Russia and France: Traditions and Modernity]. Ed. by Efremenko D.V., Lapina N.Ju. Moscow: INION RUS, 2014, pp.203–228. (In Russian)
16. Duka A.V. Problemy institucionalizacii rossijskoj politiko-administrativnoj jelity: jekonomicheskij i global’nyj aspekty [Problems of institutionalization of the Russian political and administrative elite: economic and global aspects]. In: Vlast’ i jelity v sovremennoj Rossii [Power and elites in modern Russia]. Ed. by A.V. Duka. St. Petersburg: Sociologicheskoe obshhestvo imeni M.M. Kovalevskogo, 2003, pp. 162–186. (In Russian)
17. Duka A.V. Transformacija mestnyh jelit: (institucionalizacija obshhestvennyh dvizhenij: ot protesta k uchastiju) [Transformation of local elites: (institutionalization of social movements: from protest to participation)], Mir Rossii [Universe of Russia], 1995, 4 (2), pp. 106–117. (In Russian)
18. Zudin A. Gosudarstvo i biznes v Rossii: jevoljucija modeli vzaimootnoshenij [State and business in Russia: evolution of the relationship model], Neprikosnovennyj zapas [NZ], 2006, 6 (50). URL: http://www.intelros.ru/?newsid=289 (accessed: 21.03.2019). (In Russian)
19. Kashina M.A. Zhenshhiny v rossijskih parlamentah: perejdet li kolichestvo v kachestvo? Kejs Zakonodatel’nogo Sobranija Sankt-Peterburga [Women in Russian Parliaments: Will Quantity Become Quality?], Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Filosofija. Sociologija. Politologija [Tomsk State University Journal of Philosophy Sociology and Political Science], 2020, 54, pp. 238–251. (In Russian)
20. Kolesnik N.V. Gendernye raspredelenija v regional’noj jelite (severo-zapad i jug Rossii) [Gender distributions in the regional elite (northwest and south of Russia)], Politicheskaja jekspertiza: Politeks [Political Expertise: Politex], 2009, 5 (2), pp. 72–87. (In Russian)
21. Kolesnik N.V. Gendernoe (ne) ravenstvo v politicheskoj vlasti rossijskih regionov [Gender (In)Equality in the Political Power of Russian Regions], Monitoring obshhestvennogo mnenija: jekonomicheskie i social’nye peremeny [Monitoring of Public Opinion: Economic and Social Changes], 2021, 4, pp. 468–491. (In Russian)
22. Kryshtanovskaya O.V. Biznes-jelita i oligarhi: itogi desjatiletija [Business elite and oligarchs: results of the decade], Mir Rossii [Universe of Russia], 2002a, 4, pp. 3–60. (In Russian)
23. Kryshtanovskaja O.V. Rezhim Putina: liberal’naja militokratija? [Putin’s Regime: A Liberal Militocracy?], Pro et Contra, 2002b, 7 (4), pp. 158–180. (In Russian)
24. Kryshtanovskaja O. Transformacija staroj nomenklatury v novuju sovetskuju jelitu [Transformation of the old nomenklatura into the new Soviet elite], Obshhestvennye nauki i sovremennost’ [Social Sciences and Contemporary World], 1995, 1, pp. 51–65. (In Russian)
25. Kynev A.V. Fenomen gubernatorov-«varjagov» kak indikator recentralizacii: opyt 1991–2018 gg. [Phenomenon of Governors-“Outsiders” as Indicator OF Recentralization Experience of 1991—2018 Years], Politija [Politeia], 2019, 2 (93), pp. 125–150. (In Russian)
26. Larin A.A. Ljustracija kak osnovanie ogranichenija izbiratel’nogo prava [Lustration as a basis for restricting suffrage], Teorija i praktika obshhestvennogo razvitija [Theory and Practice of Social Development], 2014, 4, pp. 246–249. (In Russian)
27. Leshkevich T.G., Ponomareva M.A. Transformacija jelit i processy modernizacii na Juge Rossii [Transformation of elites and modernization processes in the South of Russia]. Rostov-on-Don: SFU, 2011. 262 p. (In Russian)
28. Lezina E.V. Ljustracija i otkrytie arhivov v ctranah Central’noj i Vostochnoj Evropy [Lustration and File Access in the Countries of Central and Eastern Europe], Vestnik obshhestvennogo mnenija. Dannye. Analiz. Diskussii [The Russian Public Opinion Herald. Data. Analysis. Discussions], 2015, 2 (120), pp.48–89. (In Russian)
29. Muhametov R.S. Rol’ dekommunizacii v politicheskom tranzite gosudarstv Vostochnoj Evropy [The Role of Decommunization in the Political Transition of the States of Eastern Europe], Vestnik Omskogo universiteta. Serija «Istoricheskie nauki» [Herald of Omsk University. Series Historical Studies], 2018, 1 (17), 204–210. https://doi.org/10.25513/2312-1300.2018.1.204-210. (In Russian)
30. Muhametov R.S., Nagornyh O.V. Dekommunizacija v Vostochnoj Evrope: sushhnost’, prichiny i meroprijatija [Decommunization in Eastern Europe: Essence, Causes and Activities], Vestnik Omskogo universiteta. Serija «Istoricheskie nauki» [Herald of Omsk University. Series Historical Studies], 2018, 2 (18). pp. 201–207. https://doi.org/10.25513/2312-1300.2018.2.201-207. (In Russian)
31. Nisnevich Ju.A. Regeneracija nomenklatury kak pravjashhego social’nogo sloja v postsovetskoj Rossii [Regeneration of the nomenclature as a ruling social stratum in post-Soviet Russia], Sociologicheskie issledovanija [Sociological Studies], 2018, 8, pp. 143–152. (In Russian)
32. Obolonsky A.V. Ljustracija kak institut perioda tranzita: pljusy i minusy [Lustration as an Institute of the Transit Period: Pros and Cons], Voprosy teoreticheskoj jekonomiki [Theoretical Economics], 2020, 4, pp. 87–101. (In Russian)
33. Ovcharova O.G. Gendernaja asimmetrija v sfere politiki: poiski institucional’nogo reshenija problem [Gender asymmetry in politics: the search for an institutional solution to the problem], Vestnik Saratovskoj gosudarstvennoj akademii prava [Saratov State Law Academy Bulletin], 2007, № 5 (57), pp. 214–219. (In Russian)
34. Pushkareva N.L. Gde bol’she vlasti — tam men’she zhenshhin (gendernaja jekspertiza zakonodatel’stva i tekushhej zakonotvorcheskoj dejatel’nosti vysshih organov vlasti RF 1991–2006 g.) [Where there is more power, there are fewer women (gender expertise of legislation and current legislative activities of the highest authorities of the Russian Federation, 1991–2006)], Nauchnye vedomosti Belgorodskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Serija: Istorija. Politologija [Belgorod State University Scientific Bulletin. History and Political Science], 2008, 1 (41), pp. 117–127. (In Russian)
35. Regional’nye jelity SeveroZapada Rossii: politicheskie i jekonomicheskie orientacii [Regional Elites of Russia’s North-West: Political and Economical Orientations]. Ed. by A.V. Duka. St. Petersburg: Aletejja, 2001. 352 p. (In Russian)
36. Rivera S, Rivera D. K bolee tochnym ocenkam transformacii v rossijskoj jelite [Towards More Accurate Estimates of the Transformation in the Russian Elite], Polis. Politicheskie issledovanija [Polis. Political Studies], 2009, 5, pp. 149–157. (In Russian)
37. Samye vlijatel’nye ljudi Rossii. Politicheskie i jekonomicheskie jelity rossijskih regionov [The most influential people in Russia. Political and economic elites of Russian regions]. Ed. by Gaman-Golutvina O.V. Moscow: ISANT, 2004. 696 p. (In Russian)
38. Safronov V.V. Konsolidacija avtoritarizma ili demokratizacija: podderzhka putinskogo rezhima jelitoj S.-Peterburga [Consolidation of authoritarianism or democratization: support of the Putin regime by the elite of St. Petersburg]. In: Uslovija i vozmozhnosti konsolidacii rossijskogo obshhestva [Conditions and opportunities for the consolidation of Russian society]. Ed. by A.V. Duka, I.I. Eliseeva. St. Petersburg: Nestor-Istorija, 2010, pp. 30–110. (In Russian)
39. Sergeev S.A., Zinnatullin A.Z. Gubernatorskij korpus v 2005–2012 gg.: kar’ernye traektorii [Governor’s Corps 2005–2012: Career Trajectories], Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Serija: politologija [Bulletin of Perm University. Political Science], 2014, 4, pp. 122–136. (In Russian)
40. Sillaste G. Zhenskie jelity Rossii i ih osobennosti [Women’s elites of Russia and their features], Obshhestvennye nauki i sovremennost’ [Social Sciences and Contemporary World], 1994, 1, pp. 112–121 (In Russian)
41. Smirnov V.A. Litovskaja diaspora v SShA kak kanal jelitnogo rekrutirovanija v postsovetskoj Litve [Lithuanian Diaspora in the USA as an Elite Recruitment Channel in Post-Soviet Lithuania]. In: Vlastnye struktury i gruppy dominirovanija: Materialy desjatogo Vserossijskogo seminara “Sociologicheskie problemy institutov vlasti v uslovijah rossijskoj transformacii” [Power Structures and Dominance Groups: Materials of the Tenth All-Russian Seminar “Sociological Problems of Power Institutions in the Context of Russian Transformation”]. Ed. by A.V. Duka. St. Petersburg: Intersocis, 2012, pp. 40–51. (In Russian)
42. Tev D.B. Vysokopostavlennye chinovniki Administracii Prezidenta RF: kanaly rekrutirovanija i kar’era [Senior Officials of the Presidential Administration of Russia: Recruitment Channels and Career], Zhurnal Sotsiologii i Sotsialnoy Antropologii [The Journal of Sociology and Social Anthropology], 2020, 23 (3), pp. 153–187. (In Russian)
43. Tev D.B. Gosudarstvennaja Duma RF shestogo sozyva: social’no-professional’nye harakteristiki bassejna rekrutirovanija deputatov [State Duma the sixth convocation: socio-professional characteristics of the recruiting pool of deputies]. In. Vlast’ i jelity [Power and Elites], 4. Ed. by A.V. Duka. St. Petersburg: Intersocis, 2017, pp. 67–128. (In Russian)
44. Tev D.B. Partii «vtorogo jeshelona» v regional’nyh parlamentah: osobennosti bassejna rekrutirovanija deputatov KPRF, Spravedlivoj Rossii i LDPR [Parties of the “second echelon” in regional parliaments: features of the pool of recruiting deputies of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation, A Just Russia and the Liberal Democratic Party], Vestnik Permskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Serija «Politologija» [Bulletin of Perm University. Political Science], 2012, 1 (17), pp. 98–111. (In Russian)
45. Tev D.B. Federal’naja administrativnaja jelita Rossii: kar’ernye puti i kanaly rekrutirovanija [Federal Administrative Elite of Russia: Career Paths and Channels of Recruitment], Polis. Politicheskie issledovanija [Polis. Political Studies], 2016a, 4, pp. 115–130. (In Russian)
46. Tev D.B. Federal’naja administrativnaja jelita Rossii: obrazovatel’nye harakteristiki [Russia’s Federal Administrative Elite: Educational Characteristics], Mir Rossii [Universe of Russia], 2016b, 3, pp. 76–96. (In Russian)
47. Turovsky R.F. Regional’nye politicheskie rezhimy: k metodologii analiza [Regional Political Regimes: Toward a Methodology of Analysis], Polis. Politicheskie issledovanija [Polis. Political Studies], 2009, 2, pp. 77–95. (In Russian)
48. Flyagin A.M. Kak izmenilsya portret rossijskogo gubernatora: analiz biografij glav regionov. 1991–2019 [How the Portrait of the Russian Governor has changed: analysing Biographies of the Heads of Russian Regions. 1991–2019], Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. POLITOLOGIYA [Bulletin of Perm University. Political Science], 2020, 14 (1), pp. 29–39. (In Russian)
49. Hasbulatova O.A. Gendernyj podhod kak tehnologija povyshenija jeffektivnosti kadrovoj politiki [Gender approach as a technology for increasing the effectiveness of personnel policy], Zhenshhina v rossijskom obshhestve [Woman in Russian society], 2014, 4 (73), pp. 3–31. (In Russian)
50. Huntington S. Politicheskij porjadok v menjajushhihsja obshhestvah [Political Order in Changing Societies]. Moscow: Progress-Tradicija, 2004. 480 p. (In Russian)
51. Chirikova A.E., Lapina N.Ju. Zhenshhina na vysshih jetazhah vlasti. Rossijskie praktiki i francuzskij opyt [A woman on the highest echelons of power. Russian practices and French experience], Informacionnoanaliticheskij bjulleten’ Instituta sociologii Rossijskoj akademii nauk [Information and analytical bulletin of the Institute of Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences]. Moscow: Institute of Sociology of RUS, 2009. 72 p. (In Russian)
52. Shentjakova A.V. Politicheskaja i administrativnaja jelita: kachestvennyj sostav i kanaly rekrutirovanija [Political and Administrative Elite: Qualitative Composition and Recruitment Channels]. In: Rossijskie vlastnye instituty i jelity v transformacii: Materialy vos’mogo Vserossijskogo seminara «Sociologicheskie problemy institutov vlasti v uslovijah rossijskoj transformacii» [Russian Power Institutions and Elites in Transformation: Proceedings of the Eighth All-Russian Seminar “Sociological Problems of Power Institutions in the Context of Russian Transformation”]. Ed by A.V. Duka. St. Petersburg: Intersocis, 2011, pp. 145–156. (In Russian)
53. Bennett A.J. The American President’s Cabinet: From Kennedy to Bush. London: Palgrave Macmillan UK, 1996. xvi, 263 p.
54. Bermeo N. Ministerial Elites in Southern Europe: Continuities, Changes and Comparisons // Who Governs Southern Europe? Regime Change and Ministerial Recruitment, 1850 2000 / ed. by P. Tavares de Almeida, A.C. Pinto, N. Bermeo. London: Frank Cass Publishers, 2003. P. 191–212.
55. Bureaucratic Elites in Western European States. A Comparative Analysis of Top Officials / ed. by E.C. Page, V. Wright. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999. xi, 286 p.
56. Burton M.G., Higley J. Elite Settlements // American Sociological Review. 1987. Vol. 52, № 3. P. 295–307.
57. Burton M.G., Higley J. Political Crises and Elite Settlements // Elites, Crises, and the Origins of Regimes / ed. by M. Dogan, J. Higley. Lanham; Boulder; New York; London: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc., 1998. P. 47–70.
58. Burton M.G., Higley J. The Study of Political Elite Transformations // International Review of Sociology. 2001. Vol. 11, № 2. P. 181–199.
59. Burton M., Gunther R.; Higley J. Introduction: elite transformations and democratic regimes // Elites and Democratic Consolidation in Latin America and Southern Europe / ed. by J. Higley, R. Gunther. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992. P. 1–37.
60. Calder K. Elites in an Equalizing Role: Ex-Bureaucrats as Coordinators and Intermediaries in the Japanese Government-Business Relationship // Comparative Politics. Vol. 21, № 4. P. 379–403.
61. Claveria S., Verge T. Post-ministerial Occupation in Advanced Industrial Democracies: Ambition, Individual Resources and Institutional Opportunity Structures // European Journal of Political Research. 2015. Vol. 54, № 4. P. 819–835.
62. Cotta M., Verzichelli L. Ministers in Italy: Notables, Party Men, Technocrats and Media Men // Who Governs Southern Europe? Regime Change and Ministerial Recruitment, 1850 2000 / ed. by P. Tavares de Almeida, A.C. Pinto, N. Bermeo. London: Frank Cass Publishers, 2003. P. 109–142.
63. Dahrendorf R. Society and Democracy in Germany. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday & Company, Inc., 1969. xvi, 457 p.
64. Davis R.H. Women and Power in Parliamentary Democracies: Cabinet Appointments in Western Europe, 1968–1992. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1997. xi, 137 p.
65. De Almeida P.T., Pinto A.C. Portuguese ministers, 1851–1999: Social background and paths to power // Who governs Southern Europe? Regime change and ministerial recruitment, 1850–2000 / ed. by P. Tavares de Almeida, A. Costa Pinto, N. Bermeo. London; Portland, OR: F. Cass, 2003. P. 4–38.
66. Demin A., Libman A., Eras L. Post-socialist transition, authoritarian consolidation and social origin of political elites: the case of Russian regional governors // Eurasian Geography and Economics. 2019. https://doi.org/10.1080/15387216.2019.1676809.
67. Domhoff G.W. Who Rules America? Power, Politics and Social Change. 5th ed. Boston, Mass.: McGraw-Hill, 2006. xviii, 265 p.
68. Dye T.R., Pickering J.W. Governmental and Corporate Elites: Convergence and Differentiation // The Journal of Politics. 1974. Vol. 36, № 4. P. 900–925.
69. Edinger L., Searing D. Social Background in Elite Analysis: A Methodological Inquiry // American Political Science Review. 1967. Vol. 61, № 2. P. 428–445.
70. Etzion D., Davis G.F. Revolving Doors? A Network Analysis of Corporate Officers and U.S. Government Officials // Journal of Management Inquiry. 2008. Vol. 17, № 3. P. 157–161.
71. Field G.L., Higley J. Elitism. London; Boston: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1980. xi, 135 p.
72. Fischer J., Kaiser A. Hiring and Firing Ministers under Informal Constraints. Germany // The Selection of Ministers in Europe: Hiring and Firing / ed. by K. Dowding, P. Dumont. London; New York: Routledge, 2009. P. 21–40.
73. Francis S. Institutionalizing Elites: Political Elite Formation and Change in the KwaZulu-Natal Provincial Legislature. Leiden; Boston: Brill, 2011. xii, 321 p.
74. Freitag P.J. The Cabinet and Big Business: A Study of Interlocks // Social Problems. 1975. Vol. 23, № 2. P. 137–152.
75. GamanGolutvina O. Changes in Elite Patterns // Europe-Asia Studies. 2008. Vol. 60, № 6. P. 1033–1050.
76. Giddens A. Elites in the British class structure // Elites and Power in British Society / ed. by P. Stanworth, A. Giddens. London: Cambridge University Press, 1974. P. 1–21.
77. Gill G. Bourgeoisie, State, and Democracy: Russia, Britain, France, Germany, and the USA. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008. 396 p.
78. Gulbrandsen T. Elite Integration — An Empirical Study // Historical Social Research — Historische Sozialforschung. 2012. Vol. 37, № 1. Special Issue: Elite Foundations. P. 148–166.
79. Gulbrandsen T. Elite Integration and Institutional Trust in Norway // Comparative Sociology. 2007. Vol. 6, № 1–2. P. 190–214.
80. Hartmann M. Elites and Power Structure // Handbook of European Societies. Social Transformations in the 21st Century / Ed. by Immerfall S., Therborn G. Berlin; New York: Springer, 2010. P. 291–323.
81. Higley J., Burton M. Elite foundations of liberal democracy. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, 2006. vii, 229 p.
82. HoffmannLange U. Theory-Based Typologies of Political Elites // The Palgrave Handbook of Political Elites / ed. by H. Best, J. Higley. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2018. P. 53–68.
83. Huskey E. Elite Recruitment and State-society Relations in Technocratic Authoritarian Regimes: The Russian Case // Communist and Post-Communist Studies. 2010a. Vol. 43, № 4. P. 363–372.
84. Huskey E. Pantouflage à la russe: The Recruitment of Russian Political and Business Elites // Russian Politics from Lenin to Putin / ed. by S.P. Fortescue. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2010b. P. 185–204.
85. Kam C., Indridason I. Cabinet Dynamics and Ministerial Careers in the French Fifth Republic // The Selection of Ministers in Europe: Hiring and Firing / ed. by K. Dowding, P. Dumont. London; New York: Routledge, 2009. P. 41–57.
86. Keller S. Beyond the Ruling Class: Strategic Elites in Modern Society. With a New Introduction by the Author. New Brunswick; London: Transaction Publishers, 1991. xxv, 354 p.
87. Kerbo H.R., McKinstry J.A. Who Rules Japan? The Inner Circles of Economic and Political Power. Westport, CT: Praeger, 1995. viii, 217 p.
88. Kim C.L., Patterson S.C. Parliamentary Elite Integration in Six Nations // Comparative Politics. 1988. Vol. 20, № 4. P. 379–399.
89. Kryshtanovskaya O., White S. From Soviet Nomenklatura to Russian Elite // Europe-Asia Studies. 1996. Vol. 48, № 5. P. 711–733.
90. Kryshtanovskaya O., White S. Putin’s Militocracy // Post-Soviet Affairs. 2003. Vol. 19, № 4. P. 289–306.
91. Kryshtanovskaya O., White S. The Sovietization of Russian Politics // Post-Soviet Affairs. 2009. Vol. 25, № 4. P. 283–309.
92. Linz J.J., Jerez M., Corzo S. Ministers and Regimes in Spain: From the First to the Second Restoration, 1874–2002 // Who governs Southern Europe? Regime change and ministerial recruitment, 1850–2000 / ed. by P. Tavares de Almeida, A. Costa Pinto, N. Bermeo. London; Portland, OR: F. Cass, 2003. P. 38–108.
93. Matthews D.R. United States Senators and the Class Structure // Public Opinion Quarterly. 1954. Vol. 18, № 1. P. 5–22.
94. O’Donnell G., Schmitter P. Transitions from Authoritarian Rule. Tentative Conclusions about Uncertain Democracies. Baltimore; London: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1986.
95. Petrov N. Siloviki in Russian Regions: New Dogs, Old Tricks // The Journal of Power Institutions in Post-Soviet Societies. 2005. № 2. URL: http://www.pipss.org/index331.html.
96. Pinto A.C. Coping with the Double Legacy of Authoritarianism and Revolution in Portuguese Democracy // South European Society and Politics. 2010. Vol. 15, № 3. P. 395–412.
97. Pinto A.C. Political Purges and State Crisis in Portugal’s Transition to Democracy, 1975–76 // Journal of Contemporary History Copyright. 2008. Vol. 43, № 2. P. 305– 332.
98. Pinto A.C., de Almeida P.T. Portugal: the primacy of ‘independents’ // The Selection of Ministers in Europe: Hiring and Firing / ed. by K. Dowding, P. Dumont. London; New York: Routledge, 2009. P. 147–158.
99. Putnam R.D. The Beliefs of Politicians: Ideology, Conflict, and Democracy in Britain and Italy. New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1973. xii, 309 p.
100. Putnam R.D. The Comparative Study of Political Elites, Englewood Cliff s, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, 1976. x, 246 p.
101. Putnam R.D. Elite Transformation in Advanced Industrial Societies: An Empirical Assessment of the Theory of Technocracy // Comparative Political Studies. 1977. Vol. 10, № 3. P. 383–412.
102. Renz B. Putin’s militocracy? An alternative interpretation of Siloviki in contemporary Russian politics // Europe-Asia Studies. 2006. Vol. 58, № 6. P. 903–924.
103. Rivera D.W., Rivera S.W. Is Russia a militocracy? Conceptual issues and extant findings regarding elite militarization // Post-Soviet Affairs. 2014. Vol. 30, № 1. P. 27–50.
104. Rivera S.W., Rivera D.W. The Russian Elite under Putin: Militocratic or Bourgeois? // Post-Soviet Affairs. 2006. Vol. 22, № 2. P. 125–145.
105. Robins R.S. Political Institutionalization and the Integration of Elites. Beverly Hills, Calif.; London: Sage, 1976. vi, 221 p.
106. Rouban L. The Senior Civil Service in France // Bureaucratic Elites in Western European States. A Comparative Analysis of Top Officials / ed. by E.C. Page, V. Wright. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999. P. 65–89.
107. Schmidt C. Japan’s Circle of Power: Legitimacy and Integration of a National Elite // ASIEN — The German Journal on Contemporary Asia. 2005, № 96. P. 46–67.
108. Semenova E. Ministerial and Parliamentary Elites in Executive-Dominated System: Post-Soviet Russia 1991–2009 // Comparative Sociology. 2011. Vol. 10, № 6. P. 908–927.
109. Semenova E. Russia: Cabinet Formation and Careers in a Super-presidential System // The Selection of Ministers around the World / ed. by K. Dowding, P. Dumont. London; New York: Routledge, 2015. P. 139–155.
110. Szakony D. Politics for Profit: Business, Elections, and Policymaking in Russia. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press, 2020. 350 p.
111. Technocratic Ministers and Political Leadership in European Democracies / ed. by A.C. Pinto, M. Cotta, P. Tavares de Almeida. London: Palgrave, 2018. xiv, 295 p.
112. The Profession of Government Minister in Western Europe / ed. by J. Blondel, J.-L. Thiebault. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 1991. 215 p.
113. The Selection of Ministers in Europe: Hiring and Firing / ed. by K. Dowding, P. Dumont. London; New York: Routledge, 2009. 256 p.
114. Wasilewski J. Hungary, Poland, and Russia: The Fate of Nomenklatura Elites // Elites, Crises, and the Origins of Regimes / ed. by M. Dogan, J. Higley. Lanham; Boulder; New York; London: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc., 1998. P. 147–167.
115. Who Governs Southern Europe? Regime Change and Ministerial Recruitment, 1850–2000 / ed. by P. Tavares de Almeida, A.C. Pinto, N. Bermeo. London: Frank Cass Publishers, 2003. 242 p.
116. Williams K., Fowler B., Szczerbiak A. Explaining Lustration in Central Europe: A “Post-communist Politics” Approach // Democratization. 2005. Vol. 12, № 1. P. 22–43.
Article
Received: 03.08.2021
Accepted: 26.10.2021
Citation Formats
Other cite formats:
ACM
[1]
Bystrova, A.S., Daugavet, A.B., Duka, A.V., Kolesnik, N.V., Nevskiy, A.V. and Tev, D.B. 2021. Institutionalization of the Regional Administrative Elite: Recruitment Pool and Career Trajectories. Vlast i Elity (Power and Elites). 8, 2 (Oct. 2021), 21–54. DOI:https://doi.org/10.31119/pe.2021.8.2.2.
Section
Russian Elites
JATS XML
